Connect with us


Efeturi Doghudje: You Don’t Have to Make a Sequel For Every Movie… Case in Point, ‘Independence Day: Resurgence’



dreamstime_m_24369036The need to have a sequel to any movie, especially a Hollywood one can be argued; as “To have or not to have”.
Asides the overarching need by the studios to rake in more money from box office sales, prey on our intelligence and kill an already perfect plot, there are some sequels that in my opinion should never have been created, if anyone doesn’t know what I am on about right now, I am referring to the movie Independence Day Resurgence.
Independence Day Resurgence is the sequel to the American epic science fiction movie shot in 1996. It is basically directed and written by the same team of 20 years ago in the persons of Roland Emmerich, Dean Devlin, Nicolas Wright, James A. Woods and James Vanderbilt. Stars the same cast with the exception of Will Smith and the addition of Liam Hemsworth, Jessie Usher, Travis Tope and Mae Whitman.

The film focuses on the battle between ESD (Earth Space Defense), an international military defence and research organization, and the returning alien invaders during the twentieth anniversary of humanity’s first victory against the latter on July 4 – the same date as the Independence Day in the United States.

I walked into the Silverbird Cinemas on Monday, coincidentally, on the 4th of July, to see a movie and what I basically had on my mind was either “Central Intelligence” or “Warcraft” my scale of preference shifting largely to “Warcraft” when I did a complete 360 and with my colleague to boot and decided to watch IDR.
So I usually don’t review Hollywood movies, there are countless fora’s out there both local and international that do this already, I would rather focus on Nigerian movies, as there are loads to upgrade, change and make better than our Hollywood counterparts, however, IDR was totally something else.

As a 90’s girl, I watched the 1996 version of Independence Day, starring Will Smith with wide eyes and a promise to keep a look out and never be foolish enough to believe, any foreigner had the best intentions for me. Will Smith brought his comedic “Fresh Prince of Bel Air charm to the set and while it was an action packed sci-fi, after all it was an invasion, there was fun, wittiness and quirkiness to the movie. It went on to become the highest-grossing film of 1996, earning $306,169,268 in North America, and $511,231,623 in other territories. Independence Day 1 currently holds the 51st-highest worldwide gross of all time for a film, this feat and doubt will be replicated in the sequel.

So instead of celebrating a proper 20th anniversary, like having dinner, creating a museum of the costumes, makeup and other fancy things that make up a commemoration of the 20th anniversary, 21st Century Fox decides to throw in a sequel.

Here’s why the sequel didn’t work for me:
Nothing shows a celebration of an old movie than a new and improved movie but as they couldn’t get Will Smiths character to come back, that just raised the feeling in my gut that this isn’t going to work. I was not expecting a replica, but it would have been good to see how his life turned around, if he made it as an astronaut, achieved other things, broke a leg, as against just an image of him on the wall and all he represented in his son. Rumour has it he was requesting for an arm and a leg to star in this production as well as fact that shooting was on going for “Suicide Squad” but Independence Day Resurgence felt pretty empty without “Big Will”.

The lack of humour; don’t get me wrong, Liam is good to watch. Probably more of a romantic dude than a comedic actor, but it turns out most of his jokes either fell flat or failed to elicit any reaction for us. Where Liam failed is where Judd Hirsh, Dr. David Levinson father made a comeback; however, with little scene time, the lack of humour made the whole movie quite unbearable to watch.

You would think, after 20 years, there would be more to killing an alien than destabilizing its defensive shield down, like really, haven’t they advanced? Surely they would have known we would have thought about that right? With sci-fi and action thriller movies from Marvel, DC Comics and the likes coming out of our ears, the best way to kill this supposed alien queen was the same way her soldiers were killed 20 year ago, com’on! I expected more and a serious fight. There was nothing outstanding in this sequel compared to 1996 edition of the quality of sci-fi movies out in 2016; obviously 2016 United States isn’t what we see today, as it had been totally ramped up and revamped, while the simultaneous destruction of the world was also top notch. However, everything else felt like it was cued out of a PS4/Xbox video game, with a lot of CGIs to boot and then a computer generated bot from out of space, what?

Okay, maybe I am biased against sequels or I was expecting much more, from the movie that paying 1000 naira was a waste of resources but I am so against making one especially one of this nature that has nothing significant to add to the original movie.

Moving on from this movie though, I put together my list of top 5 movies that didn’t need sequels:

5. Fast & Furious 5, 6, 7 and the coming soon 8 (sue me if you want) but this movie has gone on long enough. With its over the top plots, action scenes and stunts, can they just put a lid on the Fast Movies, now to be called Furious! Dominic Toretto played by Vin doesn’t die, doesn’t get caught and has refused to settle down in life. Will he continue stealing cars, avenging friends and invading the police forever?

4. Taken 2/Taken 3: Liam Neeson killed it and was a force to reckon with in part 1. His hard hitting lines and looks sent chills down my spine with an action sequence that was fun to watch. By sequels 2 and 3, the plot had been stretched to breaking point, as it was no longer funny, memorable or entertaining to watch.
3. Pirates of the Caribbean 3: Well I enjoyed 2, it was sweet and romantic, all the drama between Orlando Bloom and Keira Knightley. By 3, I had given up hope and had grown tired of Johnny Depp’s diva movies. What exactly is it about again?

2. 300: Rise of the Empire: I was indecisive on the movie 300, maybe because of the killing and blood. But, after a while, I warmed up and began totally enjoyed the movie. The lines where the greatest part of this movie, don’t get me wrong the endurance and strength the men yielded was admirable as well but by the time 2 was produced Themistocles played by Sullivan Stapleton couldn’t do what Leonidas played by Gerald Butler could do in keeping my attention span except maybe a overtly sexual scene with the most powerful woman of the movie.

1. Ice Age: *Covering face*, I am a fan of animation and really enjoyed the Ice Age movies, but to what end? They have added female versions of all the characters, smaller animals and a plot that still focuses on migration of animals to a safer space. But aren’t they extinct already?
Have you guys seen Independence Day Resurgence and these other movies? What do you think about sequels, to have or not to have?

Photo Credit: Danie Nel |

Efeturi is an ardent lover of movies and currently the publisher of a Nigerian film critic site that reviews everything Nollywood with the aim of strengthening the Nigerian Movie Industry. She hopes to use her platform to stir the industry in the right direction and has taken steps to ensure that her reviews are fun, entertaining and punchy without avoiding the main issues which is to have world-class productions in Nigeria. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram on @Xplorenollywood and listen to her live on 92.3 Inspiration FM every Saturday at 9pm.


  1. bruno

    July 20, 2016 at 8:09 pm

    hollywood is out of ideas. sequels, prequels, spin offs, reboots etc. recycling old ideas is an easy way to make money.

    I enjoyed the 3 lord of the rings films very much then they started making prequels, this just ruined lord of the rings for me.

    same thing with pitch perfect, part 1 was so amazing and funny then they decided to cash in and make part 2 which was so unfunny and stale. fat amy was just so annoying in part 2. I heard they are making part 3. somebody pls tell them we are not interested.

    now they have made a new ghost busters with an all female cast, I heard its boring and unfunny

    charlie’s angels also. part 1 was just so good and badass. 3 girls kicking butt. it was funny and action packed. part 2 was a total disaster.

    hangover. part 1 was funny, fresh, wild etc. then they made part 2 which was just a mess. they didnt stop there, they made part 3 which was a disaster. now I hate Bradley Cooper

    they are remaking oceans 11 with an all female cast. I just hope it will be good like the original. cate blanchett is remoured to be playing the lead. I trust her and her acting.

    shrek, ice age, they keep making this movies over and over again.

    they are rebooting tomb raider. I pray it will make sense.

    some spin off and sequels are good tho. kill bill volume 1 was so good (uma thurman my girlfriend) and volume 2 was just as good. better call saul, the spin off and prequel to breaking bad is good.

    • Bodunade

      July 20, 2016 at 9:43 pm

      Better call Saul is not just good. It’s one of the best ever!!

  2. Rejoice

    July 20, 2016 at 8:12 pm

    This is such a great write-up.

    I agree, not every movie needs a sequel or a re-make.

    These days Hollywood films are all about sequels or re-makes. Running out of ideas? Time for Nollywood to work harder and be No 1, unfortunately, they always follow in Hollywood’s footstep.

    I think the world has enough stories for original films. Enough with the sequels. Hit it in 90 minutes or 120 minutes and let it go…..

  3. Iyke

    July 20, 2016 at 8:29 pm

    Making IDR without Will smith was a wrong business was a all for making sequels provided you retain the original characters.not only does it reck in more ROI,it sustains the brand.Looking forwad to the release of the Bourne Franchise.MATT DAMON spoke only 45 words in that movie and was paid $45m.Yea you heard me….$1M for every word that he spoke….and they paid because he is bankable and will smarsh the box office.

  4. Tosin Branson

    July 20, 2016 at 8:38 pm

    I haven’t seen IDR yet but I don’t think I’m ecstatic about seeing it knowing that Will Smith wasn’t a cast in the movie. Good analysis done by the critic, the points were punchy

    • lolarae

      July 21, 2016 at 10:28 am

      please dont see it. gosh. so horrible

  5. Ariere

    July 20, 2016 at 10:07 pm

    Hollywood is a Now a full fledged business, it’s no longer a medium for Art. They re not out of ideas or stories. They re just not ready or willing to green light and finance any film that seems unprofitable to them. They don’t wanna lose money. Sequels re Almost guaranteed Bets, esp if the original slayed the Box Office and was loved by the audience. These Executives re just taking calculated risks And bets. Hundreds of millions of dollars are at stake on every Blockbuster they chuck out. They determine to recoup their investment, break even and get a profit after expenses re paid.

    It’s no longer an Art form for these Businessmen. It’s not a Money making Machine. Notice how the symbolism and concept of a Movie star is dead. There re no longer Actors who can sell a movie just by their appearance in it. Now it’s all about the other ingredients: bombastic special effects, huge production and marketing budget and of course a Super hero story of good and evil showdown.

    Personally, I have given up on the machine that is Hollywood. Wanna watch meaningful movies like I do? Switch to Indies. Independent filmmakers don’t make movies necessarily to make money, they focus on the Story, characters and the importantly, the Art.

    Hollywood has bn messed up by the power and money hungry executives. It’s really all about the Box Office now and how many Merchandise and Blu Rays they can sell afterwards.

  6. Efeturi Doghudje

    July 21, 2016 at 8:58 am

    You guys have made very valid points on Hollywood, its sequels, prequels and every remake it has gone into. While they might be resting on their laurels, do you think, Nollywood should get into the trend and remake some of our classics?

  7. Bob

    July 21, 2016 at 1:35 pm

    I’m not looking forward to the indepence day sequel then.? I have to disagree with you on 300: the rise of the empire though,I could watch it everyday. I’m looking forward to a third in the series and if xerxes isn’t killed by then,I’ll probably lose interest.

  8. lynk

    July 22, 2016 at 1:58 pm

    Efeturi, Kindly focus ur comments & critique on NOLLYWOOD, expressing your displeasure at FAST & FURIOUS especially FAST FIVE is outlandish, TAKEN 2 was also a sequel I feel was worht every penny, However thanks for spurring my interest in seeing IDR

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Star Features